Can MTV Sue Nj For Nixing 'Jersey Shore' Tax Credit? (Analysis)

Ian Spanier/MTV Nj governorChris Christiemade mind lines Monday by blockinga $420,000 film tax credit that was approved through the condition Economic Development Authority to learn MTV's Jersey Shoreline. The move went in the advice in the Nj Condition-Ledger, the area newspaper, which advised the politician inside an editorial the other day to"thinkInch about nixing the borrowed funds lest the stateopen itself to have an "military of MTV lawyers" that could sue. Will there be a genuine potential situation here? The area Nj newspaper worried that reneging round the guaranteed tax incentive would open the problem to to liability for deciding that was under "content-neutral." There's been numerous cases with time that have gone completely for the U.S. Top Court over whether creating rules to encourage or discourage certain kinds of art are a breach in the First Amendment. The Very Best Court has informed in the "danger of censorship" and making coercive recommendations with conditions concentrating on a tiny bit of sound system. STORY: 'Jersey Shoreline' Condemned by Gov. Chris Christie Tax Credit Suspended But how about an over-all tax incentive for TV production together with an ailment agency's discretion to discover who reaches benefit? Taken, this very question started a suit whenSandy Frank, a producer of unscripted television shows, suedMichigan government bodies for denying him a credit. Frank's production company mentioned the rejection was aviolation of equal protection and due process beneath the 14th Amendment for the U.S. Metabolism. The problem remains pending. In the finish of the summer time, in the motion to dismiss, Michigan's attorney general organized the reasoning why the problem film office and treasury department needs to be protected from such law suits. The bottom line is: the eleventh Amendment for the U.S. Metabolism, which articulates the primary from the condition's sovereign immunity from being punished in federal court. VIDEO: Gov. Chris Christie Mocked on 'The Late Show with David Letterman' Clearly, the 14th Amendment repealed a couple of from the eleventh Amendment (as the federal government desired to eliminate slavery in a few states) and also, since, there's been a bit of the constitutional balanced exercise between federal and condition authority. Inside the pending Frank situation, producer claims you will discover enough "federal questions at problem" for your court to help keep jurisdiction, whereas Michigan states that options which entail the problem treasury, particularly for something such as film tax credits, don't pass muster. PHOTOS: The Most Effective and Worst Moments of 'Jersey Shoreline' Now onto Jersey Shoreline... Snooki together with a phalanx of MTV lawyers can certainly swoop into federal court to think about constitutional exception to Christie's statement he required to nix the "$420,000 bill for just about any project which does simply perpetuate misconceptions in regards to the Condition which is people." However, we guess the Republican governor want this type of fight. Not only would he be seen by some as meaning people, but he'd probably earn a lot more Tea Party credit by combating the invasion of government bodies. E-mail: eriqgardner@yahoo.com Twitter: @eriqgardner Nicole Polizzi MTV Jersey Shoreline